Pinheads, Dancing with God and Why I Hate Discernment by Robert Rife.

by Christine Sine

Today’s post in the series Seeking Help Through the Faith Shifting Process. is by Robert Rife.

Robert Alan Rife, is the Minister of Music and Worship for Yakima Covenant Church in Yakima, Washington. He graduated from Spring Arbor University with an MA in Spiritual Formation and Leadership. He is a singer-songwriter, studio musician, choral director, poet, and liturgist. He maintains two personal blogs: Innerwoven and Robslitbits. He also blogs at Conversations Journal and for CenterQuest. Robert describes his vocation as exploring those places where life, liturgy, theology, and the arts intersect with and promote spiritual formation.”



Historically, I have HATED the process of discernment. Why? Because it has a profound prerequisite: self-love, which requires self-knowledge which, in itself, reveals a second, foundational prerequisite: wisdom. As an often-confused adoptee, such golden gifts weren’t always forthcoming, especially when I was younger.

A common characteristic of adoptees is fear of rejection. One would think this to be self-evident since rejection, at least in broad terms, is what we have experienced even in utero. Although that probably overstates it a bit, people like me have a terrible time in the decision-making process because it includes elements that are not in our wheelhouse. For example, intentionality, which presupposes determination, which presupposes confidence, which presupposes freedom, which presupposes a general sense of acceptance, which presupposes a universe more or less benevolent, which presupposes…well, you get my point.

This process gets ramped up exponentially early in our lives when, perhaps at college, we’re not only trying to figure out where God would have us, what it is we are to be about, who we are as people and with whom we are to spend our lives, if anyone. Too much unthinking advice gets bandied about in times like these. One’s friends, equally confused, tell us, “take care lest you find yourself outside the ‘perfect will of God.’” Great, let’s add a little more fear to the mix! Worse still are the mating rituals to which we must all prescribe. They are often rituals designed to actually keep us from really getting to know ourselves let alone another human being since they, too, are built on suspicion, regret, fear and…more fear. Faith as one big ‘what if?’ or ‘should I?’

Well, I am not about to singlehandedly untie the God’s-will enigma in a simple blog post. However, allow me at least to share three gifts of great worth that have helped remove my fear of discernment.

First, as a guy now 50 years old, I have some history of decision-making. All I can say is, God’s got this. My worst decisions, ever, seem to have been redeemed quite nicely in the hands of a loving and particularly creative God. This pares down decisions not to right and wrong but good and better.

Second, it’s not just up to me. The next time some misguided but well-meaning soul comes up to you and says, “I just really feel God told me…,” let your response be, “Interesting. And to who else has God told this?” God speaks to us in community. We can get impressions and experience joy or caution, but it will be through others that the stick of God’s will gets sharpened to a finer point.

Finally, avoid a theology that dictates God’s will as the head of a pidartsn stuck in the center of a bull’s eye viewable from a full moon while facing east on Tuesday afternoons in a leap-year November. Such is not a theology at all but a control mechanism built on fear. If all is grace, then so is our process of discernment.

In the economy of God we do not trip blindly into that dark night. We dance blithely in the arms of a particularly good dancer, unafraid to take the lead and with whom every spin is ultimately in the “right” direction. So dance away, little pilgrim!


What is your greatest fear related to the will of God?

How are you engaging God in community to best discern God’s present and future for you?

Pray this: “Lord of all the universe, my past, present and future are cupped in the palm of your eternal hand. Help me to face them all with courage and confidence, recognizing that you are benevolent and strong and will never leave me to face any of it alone. Lord, since you redeem all my “mistakes” I can relax and simply dance with you in peace and unspeakable joy. Through Jesus, the one leading me on this dance floor…Amen.”

With you on the journey, Rob

You may also like


Mark Votava September 23, 2014 - 7:14 am

I am trying to listen more and speak less. I have been experimenting with contemplative activism for the past decade where I have become rooted and known in my local community for the past ten and a half years. I am leaning to experience God through gratitude, forgiveness, humility and vulnerability. I am learning to become aware of God’s presence in my context in the world and to experience God in the ordinary. I am exploring what it means for the kingdom of God to live within me, for Christ to live within me, to be an expression of love in the world. I am allowing God to disorientate me and live in my questions. I am becoming less afraid of honesty, less afraid to live into my true self even if others do not understand me. I am learning not to be boxed in by North American Christianity and live something more authentic.

robertrife September 24, 2014 - 6:27 am

If all of this is true, Mark, you are on the way to riding the wave of your own inner springs of living water toward being a word from God for others. Good on ya and peace be with you…R

Michael Moore September 23, 2014 - 8:12 am

Thanks, Rob! The discernment process can be scary and yet, as you view it, quite liberating since we are not in charge 😉

Some excellent points to ponder…

robertrife September 24, 2014 - 6:25 am

Thanks, Mark. I may have overstated my case a little here (I have that tendency) but I’m glad you got the idea!

Leave a Comment