Are All Christians Hedonists?

by Christine Sine
Art by Emmanuel Garibay Used with permission

Art by Emmanuel Garibay Used with permission

Last week I shared this quote from Business Secrets of the Trappist Monks:

It is as though the materialism that has a death grip on this culture has taken our spirituality as well. Most of what’s called spiritual is actually humanistic if you think about it. People don’t want the adventure of God on his own terms or for his own sake. They want a better world, a happier life, better relationships and all the trimmings that go along with it….. We’re urged to seek God because this human good will come of it. People don’t realize “because” implies that the end is the human good and Truth (God) merely the means” (19)

It keeps coming back to my mind. How often do I pray because I want something from God, rather than because my heart aches for deeper intimacy with God? How often do I use God as the excuse for my own self centred agendas?

Some prayers are so obviously hedonistic they make us squirm when we hear others talk about them – praying for a parking place, or going on a Jesus spending spree where we expect Jesus to guide us to great bargains. But others are more subtle. Even desiring healing of loved ones can have a self centred purpose, after all illness and death disrupt our lives physically, emotionally and sometimes spiritually. If God healed more frequently life would be so much easier.

Or perhaps we want to see people in Africa fed and freed from starvation. We hate those images of starving children, their pain and suffering disrupts our lives. Yes, some of our response comes from the compassion of God welling up from within, but for many the uppermost emotion is: If God would just do something I would not have to respond and I could get rid of my guilt and once more feel at easy in my comfortable materialistic lifestyle. Sometimes these emotions reside in our subconscious rather than conscious minds, and as long as we are too busy to reflect on why we want something to change we are never aware of our self centred motives.

One of the commonest excuses I use and that I hear others use for not taking adequate time for God or with others is: but I enjoy what I am doing. I love my work. Unconsciously what we are saying is – My personal need for satisfaction in my work takes priority over my need to spend time with God.

Sometimes we even rope God into the equation – there is so much need God must intend me to burn myself out by responding to that need. The underlying subconscious thought – without me God cannot answer this need. 

And then there is the excuse – But I have to feed and house my family. Again a very true statement and one that has many of us up at night consumed with anxiety. This believe it or not is one of those legitimate prayers. In the Lord’s prayer we regularly say Give us this day our daily bread. The problem is that we don’t expect God to provide bread for today we expect provision for the next 10, 15 or 20 years and we want to see where it is coming from NOW.

Don’t get me wrong, I am not suggesting that we don’t save for the future, though that is a way of life that some are called to, but sitting in the place of discernment, trusting that God will show us what we need to know now in order to provide, does not come easily to us. And we get uncomfortable because God might make it very clear that some of what we want for the future – like second homes, bigger cars and expensive vacations – may not be in God’s best plan for us. Even our desire for a bigger church, better paying job or higher profile ministry may not be in God’s plan – especially not if it takes time away from our number one priority – seeking God not for what we want but for what God wants – intimacy with us in every moment of the day.

What would our lives look like if we spent more time seeking God for God’s sake alone? How would it change our priorities, our time management, our use of resources? How would it affect our friendships? These are some of the questions I continue to grapple with. I hope you will take time to grapple with them too.

You may also like


Robert Lloyd Russell September 16, 2013 - 11:10 am

Thought provoking post. God bless.
~ BloggerBob, Abundant Life Now

Christine Sine September 16, 2013 - 11:13 am

Thanks Robert

contemplativeactivist September 16, 2013 - 12:01 pm

I don’t want to be awkward and this comment is very much from the core of my pilgrimage with the Divine Three. However, I am uncomfortable with the idea of spending time seeking God. Firstly, the phrase is framed in language drawn from a commercial and consumerist context. This is the oppressive constraint upon human imagination and brings an unattractive conformity to all our lives.

Secondly, after many years of seeking God it is only recently and painfully that I have come to realise God is present all of the time. It is not seeking God. Rather resting in God that is the challenge. Seeking again places the emphasis upon ME and I am to be congratulated for finding God. Many so called leaders throughout Christianity. then take and use/abuse this successful search to create consumer products to establish a market for their ministry. Quite unnecessary and always running the danger of allowing individuals to transfer their responsibility for pursuing God onto a third party to do so vicariously, I.e. on their behalf.

Resting in God has required a ruthless reappraisal followed by a challenging restructure of my life. It is unique to me yet inspired by the writings of the Contemplatives. It is a ongoing adventure in which God challenges constantly and I make choices in light of those challenges.

I love the last sentance of the quote in the above blog. Sadly we are not invited to change the world. We are invited to know God. God is then able to minister to the world as God chooses.

Christine Sine September 16, 2013 - 12:13 pm

Micah no need to apologize – I agree resting in God is a much better way to think. Even the expression “Seeking God” is self centred. It implies a special relationship in which God is interested in revealing Godself to me rather than to other “less worthy” people.

wootenelli September 18, 2013 - 11:00 am

Wow…this post blew my mind…thank you for verbalizing what I have gad so much trouble with…I pray we both are able to rest in the Lord!

Christine Sine September 18, 2013 - 11:55 am


Jim McCune September 16, 2013 - 1:06 pm

Sometimes our present needs overshadow our earnest desire to just know God. Clearly we must try to know Him, but as long as the world is as unjust and mean-spirited as it is today, I’m afraid there is little hope that our lives will be tranquil enough that we can always be philosophical rather than practical. And I for one don’t want to have to start feeling guilty for yet another thing: calling on the One who says He will be there for us when we are in need!

Christine Sine September 16, 2013 - 2:50 pm

Jim – you are right. I don’t think we should live in guilt, but I do think that if we take a little more time to rest in God as my friend Micah Jazz suggests then I think that we will find the allure of self centred religious behaviour becomes less real and attractive for us

Leave a Comment